Catalogue

A good, enjoyable read - providing interesting perspective and insights into NZ geography, history and the life of a performer. Auckland 248

Most of us enjoyed the book, and were intrigued by the life led by Lily, Mattie, Jack and their children. The presence of theatre in early NZ was also of interest. Would recommend it as an easy and light read. Ashburton 022

Everyone enjoyed the NZ context to the story, and the descriptions of well known places as they might have looked in the 1800s. It was easy to read and entertaining - some found it educational also. We would have preferred the archivist's notes to be in the form of an addendum - found them too distracting at the beginning of chapters. Christchurch 113

This was a different format to Jenny Pattrick's other books, and some struggled with notes from the archivist and posters etc, which seemed to break the flow of the story. Mixing fact with fiction is always a challenge, and "Mills & Boon' was mentioned several times... Auckland 058

Opinions were divided about this book. Several who have read other novels of hers compared 'Skylark' unfavourably. Those who liked the book however, appreciated the evocation of the period, the scenery, environment and life back then generally. The questions prompted a good discussion. Hamilton 003

A mixed response. Some members enjoyed the unusual structure, and the feeling of vaudeville with its light and darkness. Others felt it was too long and the characters not likeable enought to care about. The book evoked a lively discussion on all the topics raised in the notes, plus some family anecdotes. Auckland 071