By: WANAK 010
|
2025-07-04 12:12:12 |
|
Overall the group felt the writing was superb. Some of us had difficulty keeping track of where everyone fitted in and found the family tree in the notes very helpful. Mixed views on the footnotes with some finding it disruptive and interfering with the flow, others felt it added to the story. |
|
By: WAIUK 003
|
2025-05-28 10:22:15 |
|
All enjoyed the theme of the book. Cleverly woven story with a twist at the end. |
|
By: GERAL 002
|
2025-04-07 09:25:38 |
|
Kate Atkinson's literary style in this book is magnificent. It was, overall, a delight to read. We loved how she expressed her thoughts, and thoroughly enjoyed the unexpected humour. We found the 'Footnotes' disruptive however, and the number of characters hard to keep track of. Jumping back and forth through time was difficult. |
|
By: PALMN 029
|
2024-07-15 22:20:27 |
|
This group lead to some really interesting discussions, but the views were very mixed. A study in intergenerational trauma and how hard the lives of women over the last 140 years has been. Dark humour and detailed, vivid description kept some of us reading. Some people read the book straight through, others read the book and then read the footnotes, and some didn't read the footnotes at all. So it was a very different reading experience for each of us. |
|
By: AUCK 234
|
2022-01-26 13:34:04 |
|
In general, we all enjoyed this book. As always, with a diverse group, some enjoyed the lighter style of writing, while others enjoyed the sense of time that the author portrayed, while others had some trouble making sense of the footnotes. It's an interesting read and a really good book for a book group. |
|
By: CHCH 231
|
2022-01-26 13:31:18 |
|
All liked the book. Book notes excellent - really enhanced book. |
|
By: KATIK 002
|
2022-01-26 13:29:24 |
|
Those who had read it, loved it....many had read it previously and are huge Kate A. fans. |
|
By: AUCK 300
|
2022-01-26 13:27:59 |
|
This book stirred up lots of discussion ( still going at 11pm!). 1 person "hated" the book, quite a few loved it, and some found it hard to read but enjoyed it. |
|
By: AUCK 171
|
2022-01-26 13:26:06 |
|
Read the notes first. A little confusing with all the characters over several generations, but would probably benefit from a second read. Theme is a bit depressing but not without humour. Prose was lovely. |
|
By: CROMW 004
|
2022-01-26 13:23:11 |
|
The book was enjoyed by everyone. It was well-written but needed the reader's concentration. You needed to keep referring to the family tree to remember some of the connections. We had a really interesting discussion around the questions. |
|
By: WAIKA 010
|
2022-01-26 13:18:42 |
|
9 people - only 3 read and finished this book. Needless to say the other 6 didn't like it at all, and in particular found the plot fragmented, hard to follow, and the footnotes annoying. The 3 who completed it rather enjoyed it. Such diversity! |
|
By: RICH 009
|
2022-01-26 13:16:31 |
|
Most scored this book very highly and it generated lots of discussion. |
|
By: TARARU 001
|
2022-01-26 13:15:20 |
|
Many found the rapid changes between time/generations/family members quite confusing. It would have been helpful to know there was a family tree in the notes before starting the book. We had a very thorough discussion though on changes in family life through the decades, changes to women's roles in the home, the idea of a perfect facade to show the world. Several readers recommended other Kate Atkinson novels to the group. |
|
By: NAP 021
|
2022-01-26 13:10:54 |
|
Well, this book certainly split our group right down the middle! Great lovers of Kate Atkinson confessed to having read all of her books, whereas others of the group could not "get with this book" at all. However, we all agreed that she is a very clever author. |
|
By: ASHB 009
|
2022-01-26 13:08:32 |
|
Everyone who finished the book ( a couple didn't) enjoyed it very much. Was written well, and showed humour in otherwise not so humorous situations. One or two felt the footnotes were a tad long as far as footnotes usually go, but otherwise a great read to end the year on. |
|
|